Poison in the garden

27 Apr
Poisonous - Lily of the Valley (Maiglöckchen) along the Isar

Poisonous - Lily of the Valley (Maiglöckchen) along the Isar

Every year I hear a stray story about someone dying from eating plants that they thought were wild ramps (Baerlauch) that they picked in the English garden here in Munich. Generally what they have picked is apparently the flower known as “Lily of the Valley” which is a fairly good foil for ramps. At least if you have a stuffed nose. And they are highly poisonous.

But I had never actually seen Lily of the Valley in the English garden, which blooms later than ramps (in German they are called “Maiglöckchen” or “May bells” and indeed they bloom in late April/early May while ramps come out in April or even March), so I thought it was a lot of hogwash. Never say never. Last night I was running along the Isar in an area I rarely run in and had to stop for a moment to rest (jetlag killing me, better today.) And lo and behold – Lily of the Valley, right there next to a tree. I wasn’t actually sure – because they really did look a lot like wild ramps. So I stepped closer, sniffed, grabbed a leaf, tore it and sniffed, and realized that though the flowers hadn’t bloomed yet, there were buds there, and they had to be lilies.

I kept running after that, wondering if I would see ramps anywhere close by and indeed, about 200 meters later, there they were. A deeper green in color, and a shinier leaf, a little larger as well, but still easy to believe someone could mistake one for the other if your nose is not working. You don’t even have to reach down to grab a leaf of ramps and sniff – the garlicky scent hits you like a wall when you get anywhere near them.

Edible - Wild Ramps (Baerlauch) along the Isar

Edible - Wild Ramps (Baerlauch) along the Isar

The only thing I would actually worry about…would be if the patches of the plants were actually mixed in with one another. That could be very very dangerous. Didn’t see that, however. Still, if you didn’t know…grabbing one for the other could kill you. Don’t go out picking with a stuffed nose…


Tags: , , , , ,

2 responses to “Poison in the garden

  1. wvfarm2u

    April 28, 2012 at 2:58 pm

    I grew up in New Jersey and planted some Lilly of the Valley under my oak tree here in West Virginia. This spring was the first I received ramps in my CSA box and that was exactly what I was much the leaves look alike! But the sense of smell should be helpful.

    • diginibble

      May 1, 2012 at 11:23 am

      Yes – I think the smell should be the key. I also noticed that the leaves do feel quite a bit different. The wild ramps have a more “rubbery” feel to them and they are also a bit more delicate.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: